Over the next few weeks I'm testing whether a smart ring or screenless band, plus a regular watch for client calls, can replace my Apple Watch Ultra. This page is the plan, updated as I go.
Live test
Can a smart ring or band plus a regular watch replace my Apple Watch?
Started . No verdict yet. 3 of 5 parts of the setup are still being lined up. Tap a part to see what it has to prove.
Now: My used first-generation Apple Watch Ultra, still on my wrist every day.
Has to prove: Everything else gets measured against it. If I keep reaching for it, it wins.
Now: The Colmi R09 ring I already wear. More rings are being lined up.
Has to prove: Does a ring give me the sleep and heart rate data I actually use, without a screen?
Now: Screenless bands are being lined up.
Has to prove: Can a band with no screen cover training as well as the Ultra does?
Now: Automatic, solar and quartz watches are being lined up.
Has to prove: Does it look right on camera, stay comfortable all day and skip the charger?
Now: Smart scales are being lined up.
Has to prove: Can a scale take weight and body composition off the watch’s plate?
The scoreboard
- Missed alertsNo reading yet
- Looks right on client callsNo reading yet
- Days between chargesNo reading yet
- Health data I useNo reading yet
- Times I reached for the Apple WatchNo reading yet
I update this page as each part arrives and gets tested.
Follow the testI don’t know yet whether a smart ring and a regular watch can replace my Apple Watch. Over the next few weeks I’m going to find out, and I’ll update this page as I test.
Why I’m asking
I’ve worn a used first-generation Apple Watch Ultra every day for most of a year. It does a lot, but battery life and bedtime are where it lets me down. My Apple Watch Ultra review has the details.
I already wear a smart ring. The $20 Colmi R09 matched my Ultra’s sleep data for a week. That raised a bigger question. If a ring or a screenless band covers health and sleep, do I still need a smartwatch on my wrist during the day? Would a regular watch do that job better, and would I miss the Apple Watch?
The setup I’m testing
- Health and sleep: a smart ring, or a screenless band for workouts.
- Telling time: a regular watch (automatic, solar or quartz) that looks right on client video calls and needs little or no charging.
- Off the wrist: a smart scale for weight and body composition, so the watch doesn’t have to track everything.
What I’m judging
- Missed alerts. How many calls, messages and meeting reminders I miss without notifications on my wrist, and whether that matters.
- Client calls. How each watch looks on camera and in person, and whether it stays comfortable through a full workday at the desk.
- Charging. How often each device needs a charger, compared with my Ultra.
- Health data. Whether the ring or band gives me the sleep and heart rate data I actually use, with or without a subscription.
- The real test. How often I reach for the Apple Watch anyway.
How this page will change
I’ll add each product as I test it, with what I found, and finish with a verdict on whether I keep the Apple Watch. Until then, nothing here is a recommendation. For what to buy today, see which Apple Watch to buy and the best sleep tracker.