Buy the Withings Sleep pad if you sleep in one bed and won't wear anything: $149.95 on sale, no charging, free sleep history. Buy the Oura Ring 5 if you travel or want daytime data.
Buy the Withings Sleep pad if you want sleep data from your own bed and don’t want to wear or charge anything. It slides under your mattress, stays plugged in, and costs $149.95 at Withings during its Black Friday sale, down from $199.95. Your sleep history is free.
Buy the Oura Ring 5 if you travel often or want data from the rest of your day. It goes wherever you go, and it adds HRV, blood oxygen and temperature trends. It costs $299 in silver or black on sale, plus $69.99 a year for the full app. The pad is the wrong pick for anyone who sleeps in hotels a lot. The ring is the wrong pick for anyone who already takes a watch off at night and never puts it back on.
How I know
I haven’t used either one. This comparison is researched. The Withings side comes from its US product page and Tom’s Guide’s testing. The Oura side comes from Oura’s US store, membership and terms pages. I checked the prices and terms on November 20, 2026, except Oura’s warranty, which I checked on November 6. I do own and reviewed a $20 smart ring, the Colmi R09, and I use that experience only where I say so.
The two side by side
| Withings Sleep | Oura Ring 5 | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Pad under the mattress | Ring on your finger |
| US price, Nov 20 | $149.95 on sale, $199.95 regular | $299 silver or black on sale ($399 regular); $399 other finishes ($499 regular) |
| Subscription | Optional Withings+, $9.95 a month; sleep history free | $5.99 a month or $69.99 a year; ring works without it, with “much more limited” insights |
| Power | Plugged in, no charging | 6 to 9 days per charge |
| Tracks | Sleep stages, heart rate, breathing rate, snoring, sleep score | Heart rate, HRV, breathing, blood oxygen, temperature trends, sleep |
| Away from home | Nothing | Everything |
| Two people in bed | Tracks only the person over it | One ring per person |
| Warranty | 2 years | 1 year |
| Returns | 30-day money-back guarantee, free returns | Not listed on the product page |
Withings’ sale ends November 29, 2026, per its site. Oura’s banner says “Save $100” and shows no end date.
What the pad does well, and where it slips
The Withings pad is 5 millimeters thick and goes under your mattress. Withings says it works with any mattress except water and air beds. It uses a pneumatic sensor for heart and breathing rate and a sound sensor that picks up snoring and what Withings calls breathing disturbances. Setup is through the Health Mate app on an iPhone with iOS 18 or later or an Android phone with Android 12 or later. Withings says it can’t be set up from a computer.
Your partner doesn’t skew it. Withings says it “does not capture the movements or heart rate of a partner.” If you both want data, you need two pads.
Tom’s Guide tested it and cites a study of more than 400 nights in which its sleep and wake calls agreed with a sleep lab 83% of the time. Its reviewer also found it counted about 10 minutes of lying awake as sleep, sometimes logged daytime lounging in bed as a nap, and worked best on a bed frame without slats. Those are the trade-offs of a sensor under the mattress.
On sleep apnea, be careful. Withings sells the pad as an apnea screening device in Europe. Its US page talks only about snoring and breathing disturbances, and Tom’s Guide’s October 2026 update says US approval for apnea detection is still pending. Withings does sell an FDA-cleared version, Sleep Rx, for the US only, and it markets it to healthcare organizations. If you suspect apnea, ask your doctor about a sleep test.
What the ring does that the pad can’t
The Oura Ring 5 is 2.28 millimeters thick and weighs from 2 grams. It tracks heart rate, HRV, breathing, blood oxygen and temperature trends, and it keeps tracking during the day. Oura rates the battery at 6 to 9 days, depending on ring size and use, and says it charges in about 80 minutes.
The ring’s real advantage for a remote tech lead is travel. A week of trips leaves the Withings pad with a week of empty nights at home. The ring records every night, wherever you sleep.
The catch is the membership. Oura says the ring and app “will still function” without one, but the insights “will be much more limited.” Budget $69.99 a year. Oura also says you can export your data as a CSV file with or without a membership.
What two years costs
- Withings Sleep: $149.95 on sale, or $199.95 at the regular price. Nothing more if you skip Withings+. Monthly Withings+ for two years would add $238.80.
- Oura Ring 5: $299 on sale in silver or black, plus $139.98 for two years of membership, for $438.98. At the regular $399, it’s $538.98.
The pad costs less than half as much over two years, even at full price.
If you’d rather try a ring first
A ring only works if it fits and you keep wearing it. My Colmi R09 matched my Apple Watch Ultra’s sleep data on 5 of 7 nights in my review, and it costs $20 to $30 from marketplace sellers. It also taught me that sizing is the weak spot: size 11 missed my index finger, and I ended up wearing it on my pinky with the adjuster. My Colmi R09 vs Oura Ring 5 comparison covers that trade in detail, and my R09 sizing guide covers how to order the right size.
My recommendation
Buy the Withings Sleep pad if you sleep at home most nights and want sleep data with nothing to wear, charge or pay for every year. Buy the Oura Ring 5 if you travel often, want daytime heart rate and temperature trends, and will pay $69.99 a year for the app. If you’re still deciding between types, my sleep tracker guide compares rings, bands, watches and the pad.
FAQ
Is the Withings Sleep more accurate than the Oura Ring?
No one has published a head-to-head I could find. Tom’s Guide cites a study in which the Withings pad’s sleep and wake calls agreed with a sleep lab 83% of the time. Its reviewer also found it counted some time lying awake as sleep.
Does the Withings Sleep work with two people in the bed?
It tracks only the person lying over it. Withings says it doesn’t capture a partner’s movements or heart rate, so each person needs a pad.
Do you need a subscription for the Withings Sleep or the Oura Ring 5?
The Withings pad works without one, and your sleep history is free. Withings+ is optional at $9.95 a month. Oura’s ring works without a membership, but Oura says the insights are much more limited. The membership costs $5.99 a month or $69.99 a year.
Does the Withings Sleep detect sleep apnea in the US?
Its US page doesn’t claim it. Tom’s Guide’s October 2026 update says US approval is pending. Withings has a separate FDA-cleared version for the US, Sleep Rx, which it markets to healthcare organizations.