Italy's privacy regulator fined Meta €805 million, about $887 million, because the Facebook Android app read users' photos and videos for gallery suggestions without specific consent. What the order requires, why it matters outside Italy, and the two places to switch the feature off.
If you use Facebook on an Android phone, open the app’s camera roll settings today and decide whether Facebook should be reading your photo gallery. Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta €805 million on November 14 because the app did exactly that for about 20 million Italian users without asking them properly. Reuters puts the fine at about $887 million.
What the Garante found
The case covers a Facebook for Android feature that suggests photos and videos from your phone’s gallery as post ideas while you scroll. It has been in the app since 2023. According to Sky TG24 and Adnkronos, which both report the Garante’s findings:
- Facebook asked for gallery access through one permission that covered several features, behind a vague prompt to “enable other features.”
- The suggestion feature was switched on by default.
- That kind of permission lets the app read the whole photo archive on the phone, usually for good, and neither users nor the regulator can check what is actually used.
The legal basis is Article 122 of Italy’s privacy code, the national version of the EU ePrivacy rules. It treats the phone as part of a person’s private sphere, so any access to what is stored on it needs free, informed consent. The regulator does not have to show that data left the device or that anyone was harmed. The Garante also rejected Meta’s argument that Ireland’s regulator should handle the case: the ePrivacy rules have no one-stop-shop, so a national regulator can act on its own.
The investigation started in July 2025 after a complaint from a consumer group in Bolzano. The Garante says the fine equals about 0.47% of Meta’s worldwide turnover. It weighed the number of people affected, how long the practice lasted, a 2019 decision against the company and what it called limited cooperation. Meta changed the app after the complaint, which counted in its favor, but the regulator found the fix late and limited to people who update the app.
The case did not look at AI training, which Meta denies. A separate Facebook feature launched in 2026 that processes gallery content in the cloud will be judged in a different proceeding. Reuters, Sky TG24 and Adnkronos all reported the decision; we could not find the statement on the Garante’s own site at publication time. Meta had not said publicly whether it will appeal.
What Meta has to change in Italy
- 30 days: report the steps it has started.
- 60 days: ask for separate consent for gallery suggestions, explain what the feature does and how to turn it off, and keep it off by default, including for people who already granted the permission. If Meta misses this, the feature cannot run for anyone in Italy without valid consent.
- 90 days: report the measures it adopted.
Outside Italy, the switch is yours to flip
The order applies only in Italy. Readers in the US and Canada get no default change from it, so check the setting yourself. Meta’s own Help Center gives the path: open the Facebook menu, go to Settings & privacy, then Settings, and under Preferences tap Camera roll sharing suggestions. Turn off “Get camera roll suggestions when you’re browsing Facebook.” If the page also shows a cloud processing toggle, turn that off too unless you want Meta’s servers handling your camera roll.
Then close the second door. In Android’s settings on most phones, open Apps, then Facebook, then Permissions, and set Photos and videos to Don’t allow or to selected photos only. Facebook can still post a photo you pick each time. It just stops seeing everything else.
If your phone holds work material (whiteboard shots, screenshots of dashboards, scanned contracts), this matters more than the vacation photos. A blanket gallery permission covers all of it.
Why the fine is bigger than the feature
The Garante built this case on the ePrivacy rule about access to a device. That route skips Ireland, where Meta’s EU headquarters sit and where most of its privacy cases land. If other EU regulators use the same ePrivacy reading, any app that asks for broad photo access under a vague prompt is exposed country by country.
Sources: Reuters, Sky TG24, Adnkronos, Facebook Help Center.
